TheMaddenNFL video game series has undergone plenty of advancements since its first release in 1989. Its original goal of being a teaching tool to advance the game of football worldwide has undoubtedly been a massive success. That being said, there are plenty of examples of players featured that stand out above the rest, either intended or otherwise. While the original tecmo bowl has Bo Jackson, Madden has had 2004 Michael Vick and a litany of unpopular mechanics over the years.
RELATED:Madden 23: Best Teams to Rebuild In Franchise Mode
Given the fact that Quarterbacks have the ball every play, it stands to reason that the most noticeably overpowered player in a given year is the QB. While there have certainly been frustratingly rated players in the series history, none have caused more problems than the Quarterback.
10Donovan McNabb (Madden 06)
McNabb was known (in Madden at least) as a halfway between Vick and a traditional pocket passer. While he didn’t have the overwhelming speed that Vick did, his accuracy was better, in addition to being a right-handed quarterback, which a percentage of players still care about.
While McNabb was never outright the best quarterback in any version of Madden, rating-wise, he was consistently an effective one for around ten years. In addition to being the cover athlete in ‘06, this was also his last year with Hall of Fame wide receiver Terrell Owens, possibly the only time his Madden counterpart wasn’t saddled with lousy targets.
9Steve McNair (Madden 05)
Much like McNabb, McNair was another decent speed option for those that preferred having optimal accuracy on their quarterback. His career peaked with a co-MVP with Peyton Manning in 2003. McNair’s injury history and lack of postseason success clearly hurt him in the eyes of EA, who underrated McNair in every iteration of Madden outside of Madden 05.
Eerily similar to McNair, rating-wise, McNabb leading the Eagles to a Super Bowl appearance in 2005 likely gave him the nudge over McNair for a number of years, including a cover appearance in 2006.
8Carson Palmer (Madden 08)
Prior to his ACL tear, Carson Palmer looked poised to be among the best QB discussion alongside Brady and Manning. There was an equally brief stretch where Carson was a feared Madden QB. His smooth throwing motion along with elite WR targets in Chad Johnson and TJ Houshmanzadeh (assuming you were playing a version of Madden that had enough room to fit his last name) made the Bengals an underrated pick in competitive matchups.
While Palmer did have some respectable years with Arizona toward the end of his career, it never really translated to Madden relevancy.
7Vince Young (Madden 08)
The cover athlete in Madden 08 (for reasons that still aren’t completely understood), Young was a standout at the University of Texas, winning a national championship in 2005, but had not achieved much in his NFL career. Coming off just an okay rookie season, Young did manage to win Rookie of the Year.
RELATED:Features Modern Sports Games Are Missing
While no quarterback post-Vick was going to have as ridiculous speed and throwing power, Young was almost as frustrating to face. His 90 speed gave him similar viability for those that liked to run.
6Daunte Culpepper (Madden 06)
Despite being the cover athlete in Madden 02, Culpepper’s mid-70s speed just made him a traditional pocket passer that could occasionally scramble. Topping out four years later at a 98 overall brought his speed to a more threatening 80+.
Minnesota had only recently departed with Vikings WR Randy Moss at this time, meaning the Vikings were not as overwhelming an offensive threat as they had been in years prior, but it’s hard to ignore Culpepper’s peak here before a sharp decline just a few short years later.
5Peyton Manning (Madden 06)
While Peyton had been blessed by EA with near perfect awareness, throwing power and accuracy seemingly every year in his prime, it stood out most in Madden 06 amid the controversial ‘vision cone’ mechanic. Every other year of Madden had mastered the act of making a read and passing to the open receiver — just push the button over the head of the guy you want. Madden 06, on the other hand, decided that quarterbacks needed a yellow sight line in order to reflect where the QB was looking before making a throw.
RELATED:How the NFL and EA Nearly Ruined Football Games in 2005
Against the CPU, this was simple enough, but against another player who knows they just need to play around where you are looking, it was miserable. While most QB’s cones were just that, a cone, Peyton’s took up about 3/4ths the screen. This alone has to put him into consideration for best non-Vick choice ever.
4Patrick Mahomes (Madden 20)
Patrick Mahomes' rise was as unexpected as anyone’s in NFL history. A surprise at the 10th pick in 2017, he ran a pass-heavy offense at Texas Tech, which many thought wouldn’t translate to the pros.
When he soared as the Chiefs starter his second year, that same mobility and throw-heavy offense lead to EA re-tuning their system with the X-Factor system — not dissimilar to Steph Curry’s three point shooting and the NBA 2k series addition of badges afterward. Any player that forces you to change something fundamental about your game has clearly left an impact.
3Tom Brady (Madden 08)
While there have been plenty of great versions of Brady in Madden history, none had the tools that his Madden 08 iteration did. A spectacular offensive line, prime Randy Moss, and a similarly feared Wes Welker. His near perfect awareness, throwing power, and throwing accuracy made the Patriots a near universal pick for competitive games — excluding those that preferred a more mobile quarterback like Vince Young.
The handful of years following Brady’s ACL tear in 2009 seemed to always hamper his throwing power or accuracy; it always seemed to be one of them until the end of the decade where EA arbitrarily decided he could have both again.
2Lamar Jackson (Madden 21)
The history of scrambling quarterbacks and Michael Vick’s rise and eventual era defining play made way for run-first quarterbacks having a chance in the NFL. While there were dual threat options that saw serious usage years beforehand, like Cam Newton and Robert Griffin III, neither had the long-standing impact that Lamar Jackson has in Madden.
While he may not have the ridiculous throw power that Vick did, Jackson has comparable ratings to Vick, including a blistering 96 speed. While on paper he should have the same overwhelming ability that Vick did, the reality of modern game balancing and core design philosophy prevents any one player from having that same impact nowadays (although if this were an ugliest Madden cover contest, he’d have a better chance).
1Michael Vick (Madden 04)
Almost twenty years later, and just about any series veteran that is asked about the most broken player in Madden history willstilltell you Madden 04’s Michael Vick. This fact alone should cement his status as the most overpowered player in the history of the series. Vick’s lack of elite accuracy mattered little in tandem with unheard of speed at quarterback (95) and throwing power (97).
What tournaments were being run in person at the time had largely banned the Falcons from play to avoid having every game be Vick vs Vick. EA has attempted to recapture this iteration of Vick in Ultimate Team multiple times with middling success. You can thank the addition of console game patches and the plethora of scrambling quarterbacks in the years since for that.
NEXT:The Madden Wii Games Are a Bizarre Part of Sports Game History
